Research note / Cycle 020
Who can hold the second copy?
An internal delegated read-only checkpoint exercise defines permission without creating an independent history witness.
An authorization is not another archive
Lumen's LUM-P18 paper checkpoint has an original internal custodian and a second office slip. At 09:45 Chen asks for a read-only recovery exercise while Calder is away. The first action is a hold. Haddad is named as temporary internal deputy but can do nothing until her designation and the retained copy are acknowledged.
At 10:20 she confirms the limited role and reads the second slip. The numbered office copies match, so the team conducts only a read-only paper exercise. Calder returns at 11:30, checks the original and confirms the same internal comparison. The held period stays in the record; no real restoration or operational lunar communication follows.
Two signatures, one institution
Six separate software policy controls include a missing deputy, lost authority, absent second copy and one altered copy. Each is held. Two matching internal copies permit a read-only exercise, but a coordinated substitution of both copies produces the same decision; the control has no basis for distinguishing the two histories.
NIST SP 800-53's separation-of-duties principle helps define distinct internal responsibilities. RFC 9162 explains how separately retained log views and cryptographic consistency can provide stronger evidence in its own protocol. Lumen has not implemented that protocol, created a protected key or obtained an independent external witness.
What the second copy cannot say
The day the custodian could not answer was about the cost of an unavailable keeper. This exercise preserves that stop while making a deputy's permitted action precise: acknowledge and rehearse, not approve a production recovery.
The next question is whether a trust boundary outside the office can retain a historical view and authenticate its receipt. Neither a new name on the authorization sheet nor another local copy answers it.
Results at a glance
| Constructed case | Decision |
|---|---|
| no delegation | hold_no_delegation |
| deputy absent | hold_deputy_absent |
| missing second view | hold_no_second_internal_copy |
| one copy substituted | hold_comparison_conflict |
| two internal views match | read_only_internal_exercise_only |
| coordinated substitution | read_only_internal_exercise_only |
External research and methods
- Certificate Transparency Version 2.0 · Ben Laurie, Eran Messeri and Rob Stradling · RFC 9162, Experimental (2021-12). Sections 2.1.4 and 11.3: consistency and auditing.
- Security and Privacy Controls for Information Systems and Organizations · National Institute of Standards and Technology · NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5, AC-5 (2020; updates through 2025 release note). AC-5 Separation of Duties and its limits.