Research note / Cycle 023

The reply we had not sent

· Mara Voss, Jonas Reed

A file review finds an unanswered January request from North Quay. The reply reports a mock-up that cleared the clamp and flexed, and asks six questions the cooperative is free to decline.

A request already on file

The Space Elevator Initiative’s strip bench needs a reference that does not share the motion of the fixture it checks. After A stationary number is not a stationary reference, the next step looked like a new request to North Quay Instrument Cooperative, which lent the NQ-17 comparator in December. Before writing one, Voss and Reed read the correspondence file in date order on February 19.

The last message in it was not ours. On January 23, reviewing the paired-target drawing described in Two targets around the clamp, North Quay asked for clearance and rigidity observations once a mock-up existed. The mock-up was made two days later and reported in A path around the clamp. No reply went to North Quay. The four notes that followed examined whether a third witness could be independent and did not return to the request.

What the reply reports

The reply has two parts. Reed wrote the first, an account of what was observed. On January 26 the card-and-plywood mock-up SE-M18 fouled the occupied clamp on the straight approach and passed by both offset approaches at the marked centre and end positions in each travel direction. Light finger pressure visibly flexed it. No force and no deflection were measured, so there is no rigidity figure to report. The mock-up was removed and nothing has been built since.

The account also states what the paper reviews found: every place a third reference could stand is carried by the same floor, and Meridian has no measurement of that floor’s motion. It restates the January 6 session from The last hour of the loan, in which North Quay’s own comparator and KIS-61 both gained 4 µm when the shared target was moved by hand and both rose 8 to 9 µm in the hour before, with their difference at 1 µm throughout. That shows two instruments following one target. It does not show that their supports were still.

What it asks

Voss wrote the second part, because a loan and its terms are a resource decision. The six requests are in the table. Three references shaped them. NIST Technical Note 2156 states that metrological traceability is a property of a measurement result, supported by a documented chain of calibrations and an evaluated uncertainty, and that having an instrument calibrated is not enough. The fourth request therefore asks what could be stated about a result. It does not ask whether an instrument is certified. NIST Technical Note 1297 keeps a covariance term for inputs that are not independent, which is why the fifth request asks about shared motion and does not assume a second stand removes it.

The fifth request also separates two things. Colin Gordon’s paper on generic vibration criteria describes floor limits as rms velocity in one-third octave bands, relaxed below 8 Hz, with an extension down to 1 Hz only proposed. A floor could meet such a criterion and still carry the slow change of several micrometres over an hour that both instruments showed after power-on. None of these sources describes Meridian’s room, North Quay’s instruments or any agreement between the two.

What has and has not happened

Voss approved the reply and it was sent by email to the cooperative’s survey contact on the morning of February 22. No answer had arrived when this note was written. The reply tells North Quay that it may decline any or all of the requests or propose other terms, that Meridian will record a decline as an answer and will not treat silence as agreement, and that no second request will be sent before March 8. Any reply will be quoted only with the cooperative’s consent.

Nothing was measured or installed. NQ-17 remains returned, and KIS-61 and KB-2 are unchanged. The third-point hold stands with its open question, and loading and acceptance remain withheld. The 25 µm budget, the separate 6 µm return allowance and the 1000 µm bidirectional grid are unchanged.

Results at a glance

RequestSubjectWhat the reply asks North Quay
1RigidityWhether rigidity observations are still wanted and in what form: what load, applied where, with deflection read by what.
2Whose supportWhether the cooperative would consider a comparison in which the reference instrument and what it stands on are its own, placed and described by it.
3A known displacementWhether it could apply or witness a displacement of known size at the target, with the documentation for that size.
4What could be statedWhat it could state about the quantity measured, the reference and its calibration history, the uncertainty and the conditions.
5Shared motionWhat would have to be measured or stated before it would treat its reference as not sharing the fixture’s motion, asked separately for vibration and for slow change over an hour.
6TermsCustody, transport, duration, return and damage terms, and any limits on what Meridian may publish.

External research and methods

Related records

← Collective journal