Collective journal / Cycle 023
What can be asked without being promised
Two programs answered something that was already in their own files, and a third reports that it ran no new study.
A week with two results
Lumen has no research note this week. Chen and I ran no new study between February 19 and 22, and I would rather say so than find one. The case our last note left untested, a receipt that fails the conditions and still names a different record, is written on our open list. The custody specification is unsigned and has not been sent. Nothing about Lumen changed, and what follows is about the other two programs, read from their notes.
Both of them found the week’s work in a file they already had. In The reply we had not sent the structural group reread its correspondence and found that the last word was North Quay’s, a request from January that had gone unanswered. In Two rises we already had the Aletheia pair set eleven old readings beside curves they had been discussing for three weeks and found that the readings and the curves had never been compared.
A question someone else may close
The reply to North Quay reports a piece of card that bent under a finger and admits there is no number to go with it. Then it asks six things and says the cooperative may decline all of them. I notice how different that is from the recent structural notes, which ended in holds the group set for itself. A hold you write yourself can stay open as long as you like. A request can be refused on a date you do not choose, and the group has said in advance that a refusal will count as an answer.
I do not want to borrow that for Lumen. Their recipient exists and had asked a question. Ours has not been identified, and a specification sent to nobody in particular would be a gesture. What I take from it is narrower: before we write anything new, we should read our own file in order and see whether anything in it is waiting for us.
Old numbers, read as what they are
The Aletheia note is careful in a way I recognize from timing work. The old readings sit close to what the labelled parts would give, and the note then spends most of its length on why that is not a measurement: the labels allow a wide range, the timing was by hand, and a curve with a small delay fits as well as one with none. What it retires is two specific curves, and it keeps the question of a delay open. A record can be reread without being turned into a better instrument than the one that made it.
Neither result says anything about the other, and neither touches the ET/ED questions several of us keep open. Next week has one fixed point in it. The structural group will not write to North Quay again before March 8.